Why a second job is taxed differently
When you take a second job, your personal tax-free allowances and credits are already consumed by your main employer. The second employer has no allowance left to apply, so your second income is taxed from the first pound, euro, or dollar at your marginal rate — the rate that applies to the top slice of your total earnings.
This does not mean the tax system penalises second jobs unfairly. It simply reflects the fact that progressive tax applies to your total annual income, not to each job separately. Whether you earn all your income from one employer or split it across two, the total tax liability is the same — the difference is how it is collected during the year.
How each country handles it
| Country | Withholding method | Personal allowance | Settlement |
| Netherlands | Marginal Box 1 rate via bijzonder tarief | Kortingen on main job only | Annual aangifte (tax return) |
| United Kingdom | Flat BR (20%), D0 (40%), or D1 (45%) code | Fully used by main job (1257L) | HMRC self assessment or PAYE adjustment |
| United States | Aggregate — based on total annual income | Standard deduction applied once | Annual Form 1040 filing |
Frequently Asked Questions
Will I always pay more tax on a second job than a first?+
Yes, in the sense that each unit of second job income is taxed at a higher marginal rate than the early units of your main job income, which benefited from the tax-free personal allowance and lower rate bands. However, your total annual tax bill is the same whether you work one job or two with identical combined income — the difference is timing and withholding method, not total liability.
What is a BR tax code in the UK and can I change it?+
BR stands for Basic Rate and means HMRC has instructed your second employer to deduct income tax at 20% on all earnings from that job, with no personal allowance applied. This is the default code for most second jobs. You can request a different code from HMRC if you believe your personal allowance is not fully used by your main employment, for example if your main job income is below the personal allowance threshold.
Do I pay National Insurance on a second job in the UK?+
Yes. National Insurance is calculated separately for each employment. Each employer applies the primary and upper earnings limits independently. This means that if your earnings from both jobs are below the primary threshold individually, you may owe less NI overall than the combined calculation shows. If each job separately exceeds the primary threshold, both will deduct NI, and you may overpay and be entitled to a refund at the end of the tax year.
How is a second job handled in the Netherlands?+
In the Netherlands you should only activate the loonheffingskorting (wage tax credits, including the algemene heffingskorting and arbeidskorting) with your main employer. Your second employer should withhold loonheffing without these credits, which means the second income is effectively taxed at the marginal Box 1 rate. If you incorrectly activate credits with both employers you will underpay and will owe the difference when you file your annual belastingaangifte.
Is it worth taking a second job given the tax cost?+
That depends on your marginal rate and the value of your time. If your combined income puts you in a 40% tax bracket, you keep 60 cents of every extra pound earned, before any social contributions. At very high incomes the UK personal allowance taper creates a 60% effective rate on income between £100,000 and £125,140. For most people earning moderate incomes the net return on a second job is still meaningful. The key is to calculate the actual net income rather than the headline rate, which is what this calculator does.